What is it with the wildly varying proportions in recipes for making mint jelly?!
I made apple mint jelly once before, using a recipe from a Reddit thread because I had a lot of gleaned apples that year and could make the recipe that involved cooking the apples down, extracting juice, and adding vinegar. Yes, this is extra work, but a number of mint jelly recipes call for this approach. Apple juice as medium, essentially.
Right now it isn't apple season but boy, do I have mint (as one does), so I decided to make it using some bottled apple cider I have on hand.
Various recipes call for cooking the mint leaves in water or juice, then going forward with the recipe. I don't want to use pectin so I'm going to lean on apple juice plus some added lemon juice. I remember doing this with the previous batch and getting a good jell.
The proportions thing, though.... After cutting all the mint in the yard, stripping leaves, and setting the small leaves aside to dry for mint tea, I have 2 cups. Do I start with a recipe based on one cup and scale everything up accordingly? If I do that, which one-cup recipe do I start with—the one that has a 1:1 ratio of mint to liquid or the one that has 1:4?? (That one just sounds weak-ass, if you'll pardon the term.) The National Center for Home Food Preservation does a lot of testing, particularly for whether the ratios are food safe, so I'm inclined to stick with them and ignore their use of pectin. Below my recipe I list the sources I consulted with their varying ratios, what liquid they used, and whether pectin was involved.
Ingredients
2 cups packed mint leaves, roughly chopped
3 cups apple cider (I used commercial cider because I had it on hand and it's time to use it up; this could be apple juice instead)
2 cups sugar
2 T. lemon juice
~1 T. dried mint leaves, optional
So my starting ratio is 2:3:2, plus 2 T. lemon juice.
Instructions
Read the National Center for Home Food Preservation on canning basics if this is your first time on the merry-go-round.
Sterilize your canning jars and get everything ready.
- I put my jars on a big roasting pan in the oven at 200 degrees for at least 10 minutes. Timing this right gives you warm jars when you're ready to put hot product into them, which is important; hot jelly going into a cold jar can crack it.
- Put a small plate in the freezer to use for your jelling test.
- Get that big pot of water warming. If you're using a full-sized canning kettle it will take a while. I sometimes use my soup pot for a smaller batch, placing a metal trivet in the bottom to keep the jars from touching the heat directly. I may also speed things up by using my hot-water kettle for a faster heating of a smaller quantity and pouring that in, maybe doing this a couple of times.
Extract mint-flavored juice. Bring the chopped mint and apple juice or cider to a boil in a large pan such as a Dutch oven. You can muddle the leaves a bit with a potato masher if you like. Once the juice has come to a boil, cover and set off the heat to steep for 10 minutes or so. Strain the leaves out and toss them in the compost.
Make the jelly. Place the minty juice in a Dutch oven or other large, heavy pan. Stir in the sugar and lemon juice. On high heat, bring to a boil, stirring constantly. Cook until the liquid runs together when you lift the spoon, or test on that plate you put in the freezer to see if the liquid will wrinkle when you run the tip of a spoon through it. This will take a while because we're not using pectin in this recipe. I used a thermometer, but I find that even when I don't hit the recommended 220 degrees if I've gotten over 205 my products will set up.
Optional mint intensification. Taste the liquid early on (carefully! It's very hot!). If you'd like the flavor to be a bit more minty (mintier?), place the dried mint leaves in a teaball and put that in the liquid to steep while it's coming to the jelling stage. I did that for this batch and my official taste tester said it's the perfect mintiness, meaning it's very minty.
Canning step. Pour the hot jelly into hot, sterile jars, leaving ¼ inch headspace. Wipe the rims with a dampened clean paper towel; put the lids on. Process 10 minutes in boiling water, timing it from when the water returns to the boil after putting the jars in.
Yield: 5 quarter-pints that jelled beautifully with zero pectin. Picture below only shows four because one has already been used up by Chief Taste Taster, aka my Sweet Hubs.
What I don't do that you may find in other recipes.
- I don't add a drop or two of green food coloring because I like the natural golden color. That commercial mint jelly looks like Jell-O to me. If the bright green is important to you, by all means go for it.
- I don't save some fresh mint leaves to chop fine and stir in at the end as the jelly goes into the jars. Some people like little things floating in their jelly. I don't.
- I also skip skimming the foam in some recipes. I stir it down and mix it in. If it really looked foamy all across the top of the pan I might skim it. When I do, I put the foam in a little jar to go in the fridge because it's perfectly good! In peak canning season I might end up with a jar of mixed flavors from three or four different recipes and it can be delicious, a sort of bumbleberry jam by proxy.
Mint Jelly Recipes
List below has the recipes I consulted and the proportions, along with whether or not they add any lemon juice or vinegar (another element that varies widely) and whether they use pectin.
Ratios listed are in cups for mint:water:sugar, with a note if the recipe calls for apple juice instead of water. I'm listing them in order by the volume of mint leaves and liquid. If the recipe calls for apple juice then it shouldn't need as much sugar for sweetness, although it needs it for jelling action.
- Mint Jelly #2, NCHFP: 1:1:3.5; 1/2 c. vinegar; uses pectin
- Mint Apple Jelly, Andrea's Recipes: 1:4:4.25; uses pectin
- Mint Jelly #1, NCHFP: 1-1/2:2-1/4:3-1/2; 2 T. lemon juice; uses liquid pectin
- Ball Canning (via Reddit; not on their site now): 1-1/2-2:2-1/4:3-1/2; 4 T. lemon juice; uses pectin
- Mint Jelly, Canning Diva: 1-1/2:2-1/4:3-1/2; 2 T. lemon juice; uses liquid pectin
- Classic Mint Jelly, Serious Eats: 2:2:2; 1 c. vinegar; uses pectin, specifically Pomona's so you also need to have calcium water on hand and I do not
- Mint Jelly Recipe Without Pectin, Learning and Yearning: 2:2:3; 1/4 c. lemon juice
- Apple-Mint Jelly with Fresh Mint, Brown Thumb Mama: 2:3-1/4 apple juice:3.5; 1/2 t. lemon juice; uses pectin
- Unknown source from that Reddit thread: 1-1/2:4-5 c. (apple juice produced from apples, plus 2 c. white vinegar):3-1/2 c. (helpful ratio here: 7/8 c. for each cup of juice)
Related Reading and Recipes
- Mixed Citrus Ginger Marmalade, Take 2
- Spiced Apple Butter Recipe
- Green Tomato Chutney Not-a-Ketchup Sauce
- In Which I Say Never Again to Making Ketchup
- When Life Hands You a Defrosted Freezer, Make Jam
- My Circular Economy of Apples
- Making Taybarb: Tayberry Rhubarb Jam Recipe
- "Sweet Harvest"
- Canstravaganza! Food Preservation 2024
- Blackberry Apple Chutney Recipe
- Green Tomatoes. So Many Green Tomatoes.
- Apples, Apples, Apples!
- Zucchini Tomato Salsa (Everyone Needs Salsa, or, What to Do with a Really Giant Zucchini)
- Tomatoes, Tomatoes, Tomatoes!
- Pears, Pears, Pears!
- Future Marmalade
- Vegan Cranberry Caramelized Red Onion Orange Chutney Recipe Experimentation
- All my posts on food, gardening, and the environment